Your Rating for EPISODE I, Out of 10, how would you rate it?

So, out of 10 stars how would you rate KOTOR episode I?

10 as soon as the SE comes out! right now its about an 8.

I give it a 9/10. Its pretty much one of the best most well edited, cinematic Machinima, fan films out there. I seriously can't wait till the special edition and Episode II comes out.

Well put, I agree to 100%.

Well put, I agree to 100%.

i agree. once SE comes out i'd give it an 11!

Well, considering the facts that it does stay true to the game, provides amazing quality considering the fact that it is entirely made in game and near real time. This to me is considered an inspiration not just for Star Wars fan films, but Machinima in general, might I say Kaydon, you have brought a lot of people into a new world. You have also inspired people to make their own adaptations of this epic tale, and for that we thank you.

Overall: 10 out of 10.

Definitely a 9.

It's near perfect, good voiceovers, and great camera angles.

But if I'm correct, the SE is going to refine alot of the movie, in which this movie gets an 11.

Yep, I like this movie so much, I printed out a cover and back cover for the DVD case.

I got it on DVD, it definitely captures the KOTOR experiece.

I simply gave it a 10 because it was the best fan film I've ever seen, to this day. It has earned a place on my shelf with all the other Star Wars films. The Special Edition will be even better, so I'm very excited for that.

For a Fan film I'd give it a 6 or a 7. For a real film maybe a 4 or 5.

Dude, judging from your rating on it...what the hell are you doing here? And I mean that. Seriously.

I'm here because Episode I was pretty good for a fan film and Episode II looks SUPER SUPER promising. I'm also here to see other takes on the KOTOR universe and just a KOTOR fan in general.

And as for my rating of Episode I, I'm just giving my honest opinion. No harm meant by it which is why I want to see the Special Edition clean up the rough spots that keep it back from a better rating.

10 out of 10 for definate!! It is a amazing film!!

I'd give it a 6 or a 7.

I'd give it like a 7 or an 8, and I say that because it was really good, but there was still room for improvement. I mean, we pretty much all agree that Ep 2 will be better than Ep 1, but there are people here who will say Ep 2 is way better and still give both movies 10/10. That just doesn't make sense.

Honestly? I'd give it a 7. From an outsiders point of view, the editing in the first half...well...is kinda shite. It does hold true to Star Wars, but Star Wars is also flawed. It is by no means perfect, but it is no means bad, its just good, bordering on great. But problems hold it back. So far, this trilogy is not going to change things like RVB or The Codex, but its a fun project.
NITPICK MODE OVER.